Hal Carter (William Holden), a football star in college and a failure at everything since, hops off a freight train with nothing but the ragged shirt on his back. He arrives at a last resort: the small town in Kansas where his fraternity mate, Alan Benson (Cliff Robertson), the well-to-do son of an industrialist, lives. It is Labor Day, 1955, and everyone has the day off, but Hal offers to do back-yard work for Mrs. Potts (Verna Felton), the kindly old lady who feeds him and obligingly offers to wash his shirt, thus giving us a look at his buff, shaven chest.
The “us” in that last sentence includes Benson’s girlfriend, Madge Owens (Kim Novak at her most stunning). At the town’s annual Labor Day picnic, Madge will be crowned the Queen of the Neewollah (Halloween spelled backwards). Many, including Millie (Susan Strasberg), Madge’s young sister, drink too much at the picnic, and Hal gets blamed for everything that goes wrong.
Neither Holden nor Novak is a natural dancer, but when they dance at the picnic to the tune of “Moonglow,” the sparks fly. Whereas Novak and James Stewart play out a passionate romance on the interior level of the psyche in Hitchcock’s Vertigo, the physical attraction between Novak and Holden is electric. Benson castigates the “same old Hal” to whom he had earlier promised a job, albeit as a “wheat scooper” rather than the executive positon Hal had unrealistically hoped for. Hal leaves town the same way he arrived, only this time, Madge packs a suitcase and plans to take a bus to meet him in Tulsa.
Rosalind Russell and Arthur O’Connell give outstanding performances as the town’s frustrated schoolmarm and her reluctant suitor, who must settle for what small-town life can give them. Joshua Logan directed this film adaptation of William Inge’s Broadway play. See Picnic on Labor Day weekend if you can. It’s hot.
For recommendations on movies for Halloween (Arsenic and Old Lace) and Thanksgiving (Hannah and Her Sisters), click here for my "Talking Pictures" feature that appeared in The American Scholar of August 28, 2021.
from the archive; posted Labor Day 2022
Holden and Novak, two of Hollywood's lousiest dancers, set off sparks, hardly touching, moving to "Moonglow" in this fabulous, classic movie. Happy Labor Day! P.S. Yes, Holden is way too old for this role, but after you see him and Kim Novak together, you won't care.
Posted by: Emily Fragos | September 05, 2022 at 01:34 PM
David, you are so right about this movie. The picnic dance is amazing. Thanks, in part, to Holden (a professed non-dancer) having had a drink or two first--normally verboten on Logan's set. The DVD cover is wild--dueling torsos!
Posted by: Angela Ball | September 05, 2022 at 08:57 PM